Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Mayor: No Evidence of Teen Pregnancy Pact




Mayor: No Evidence of Teen Pregnancy Pact

1. How media piece frames the issue at hand

The media piece frames the issue at hand as a debate in the community over the innocence and sexuality of its youths. The piece also presents information that places responsibility of teen pregnancies on popular culture and the economy.


a. Distinguish headline from body of the article

“Mayor: No Evidence of Teen Pregnancy Pact” does indeed present information regarding the debate that arose after the first report in Time magazine presenting the rise in teen pregnancy rates at Gloucester High. The mayor and superintendent refute the statement that the principal made regarding the “pregnancy pact” that a group of students made. Later in the article, however, the idea of popular and celebrity culture as influential in rising teen pregnancies rates is presented and this “new area” of risky teen behavior is identified.

b. Analyze which arguments are more prominent

According to Linda Boesky, psychologist and writer of "When to Worry: How to Tell If Your Teen Needs Help - And What to Do About It" - "We're facing a new area in teen pregnancy." She says that "If you look at all the celebrity magazines, celebrity TV shows, you can't turn ap age without seeing more and more celebrities getting pregnant." She explains that popular culture is responsible for the high pregnancy rates. In other words, old values and times are being discarded, hurting the young children in our country.

c. Which characters are quoted? Not quoted? Why?

Carolyn Kirk, Mayor of Gloucester
Christopher Farmer, Superintender of Gloucester Public Schools

Linda Boesky, CBS Early Show psychologist and author

Health officials are not directly quoted
Joseph Sullivan, Principal Gloucester High School
Sue Todd, CEO of Pathways for Children

The mayor and superintendent of Gloucester, MA held a meeting but did not invite Principal Sullivan. Their intention was to discredit what the principal of Gloucester High had said in an interview with Time magazine regarding a "pregnancy pact" that students had made together. The superintendent and mayor completely silence the principal by not inviting him to the meeting and seek to re frame the issues at Gloucester High on their own terms.

2. What’s left out from the discussion in the articles?

Similar to the previous article, what is left out is an interview with the pregnant teens themselves. Also left out and absent from the discussion was the principal of the high school, as well as direct quotes from the health professionals who worked closely with the students. Furthermore, no national pregnancy statistics are presented to serve as a point of comparison to the "quadruple" in pregnancy numbers at Gloucester High.

3. What ideologies are used to construct the arguments?

The most prominent ideology that is used to construct the argument is the idea that teens are in danger and that there is a new danger our youths are facing. Teens are described to be generally irrational: “some girls gave high-fives and planned baby showers while others were sullen if their pregnancy tests at the high school clinic came back negative.” The focus on this generalized group of female students falls solely on their gender and sexuality and nothing else. The media, with all its resources and skills in the reporter’s repertoire, has not provided any information about a single pregnant student besides the fact that they are pregnant.
Another idea conflict that is presented, as explicitly stated in the title of the article, is the dispute over which authority figure can define and classify the events of the school. This is especially interesting because there is a kind of double-consciousness that is revealed: the principal’s words are vehemently disputed by the superintendent and mayor and various characters are taking sides to frame the behaviors of the adolescents in the high school. They are trying to enact their own filter, and the article through which the dilemma is presented is also engaging in its own filter when it problematizes teenhood and sexuality.



Pregnancy Boom at Gloucester High



Pregnancy Boom at Gloucester High

1. How the media piece frames the issue at hand

The article frames the story as a decay of a predominantly conservative, Catholic town as it confronts the decline of society at large. The piece portrays adolescents, especially young women, as helpless and incapable of independence and problematizes teenhood and sexuality, as well as the collective female body.

a. Distinguish headline from body of the article

The article “Pregnancy Boom at Gloucester High” begins seeks to shock the reader by presenting two ideas that are in opposition in the consciousness of the American public: “As summer vacation begins, 17 girls at Gloucester High school are expecting babies…” Immediately, one can read that the issue is being framed as innocence (“summer vacation”) lost (“expecting babies”).
In the same opening paragraph, as Kingsbury narrates the discovery of the pregnancy “boom” at the high school, she writes that “the story got worse: according to the principal,“…one of the fathers is a 24-year-old homeless guy.” This writer is unsure of which revelation the writer intended to emphasize - is the situation worse for the mother and fetus worse because the father is homeless or is it because he has committed statutory rape?


b. Prominent arguments

The article correlates the rise in teen pregnancy with the decline in economy. Kingsbury writes that the “past decade has been difficult for this mostly white, mostly blue collar city…(and) in recent years, such jobs have all but disappeared overseas, and with them much of the community’s wherewithal. “Families are broken,” says school superintendent Christopher farmer, “Many of our young people are growing up directionless.” The writer argues that the decline in the economy is linked to social problems in the community. The “young” are growing up “directionless” because the old values and morals, such as the role of the family, are deteriorating.

c. Which characters are quoted? Not quoted? Why?

Quoted:
Christopher Farmer, Superintendent of Gloucester Public Schools
Joseph Sullivan, Principal of Gloucester High School
Amanda Ireland, 18, mother and recent graduate from Gloucester High School
Kacia Lowe, rising junior at Gloucester High School
Sue Todd, CEO of Pathways for Children, day-care center at Gloucester High School

Not quoted:
17 Gloucester Students, pregnant
Kim Daly, nurse practitioner
Dr. Brian Orr, local pediatrician
Economists, Sociologists, Teen counselors and psychologists

They are not quoted because they did not respond when reached for comment. The people who are absent in this article seem to be the people who would be most informed about the issue as they interact directly with students in administering hundreds of pregnancy tests. The teens declined all interviews, perhaps because they do not want to receive any more attention from the media and press. Amanda Ireland, who is a teen mother, is interviewed as her words of warning and regret are intended to represent the whole of adolescent experience.


2. What’s left out from the discussion in the articles?

What’s left out of the discussion is any positive message. There is no praise for the high school in providing support systems, such as a free on-site day-care center, for their students so that young mothers can continue to receive an education. The writer even implies that the high school services for young parents might have served as an incentive for students to have babies. No students are interviewed about their views and needs regarding contraception, nor are members of the community. Also, statistics regarding the actual economy of Gloucester are not presented.

3. What ideologies are used to construct the arguments?

The ideology that women’s bodies need to be controlled and monitored is used to construct this sensationalized argument. There is also an ideology of proper teen behavior and how teens should behave. Adolescents are a danger to themselves, and adults must decide what is best for them. Even informed health officials “have no right to decide” whether or not sexually active teens can have access to contraception. There is also the ideology regarding the powers of a free market: a decline in the economy results in the deterioration of social and moral values. The writer of the article describes the economic conditions of the town as a factor in the rise of teen pregnancies. In fact, the annual household median income for the town of Gloucester is higher than the national median income. These issues relate to dominant and non-dominant ideologies in our society in terms of their view on adolescents and female bodies. Furthermore, there seems to be some nostalgic view of what the past was like whenever the writer tries to connect the decline in the economy to the rise in pregnancy rates - she tries to present the idea that the deterioration of the economy and old moral values directly relate to the seventeen pregnant teens. Yet by the end of the article, I am not informed as to the state or condition of these young women, just the spectacle surrounding them.

Ideologies

Ideologies


Ideologies are ultimately based on persuasion as a form of social power. Persuasion entails not just making claims but getting others to go along as well…the type of explanation or ideology varies depending on the type of inequality (McNamee & Miller, 2-3).

Information is disseminated to the public through networks and channels of print, radio, and video, but the news that is presented is not always “just the facts.” Very often, reports are framed in various ways to strike the interests of the audience: controversial headlines, visually stimulating video-editing, shocking images, sensationalized investigations, and topics that deal with violence and sex. It is difficult to remember that writers and editors intentionally filter reports and frame issues in ways that may silence or promote particular views in society. In these two articles, ideologies are present in the way adolescents are portrayed: they are helpless, irrational and there is a new era in risky teenage behavior. This "new" problem of teenhood is related to the ideology that the decline in culture and moral value directly influences the youths of the country.